Discussion of movies and ReelThoughts topics
|
It is currently Thu May 23, 2013 9:29 am
|
View unanswered posts | View active topics
|
Page 1 of 1
|
[ 8 posts ] |
|
Rank/rate the Oscar nominees (all categories)
| Author |
Message |
|
robhumanick
|
 Rank/rate the Oscar nominees (all categories)
So as to get a rounder view of everyone's awards experience this year. Which of you are throwing/attending Oscar parties this weekend, btw?
Full list:
Australia The Baader Meinhof Complex The Betrayal Bolt Changeling The Curious Case of Benjamin Button The Dark Knight Defiance Doubt The Duchess Encounters at the End of the World Entre Les Murs Frost/Nixon Frozen River The Garden Happy-Go-Lucky Hellboy II: The Golden Army In Bruges Iron Man Kung Fu Panda Man On Wire Milk Okuribito The Reader Rachel Getting Married Revanche Revolutionary Road Slumdog Millionaire Tropic Thunder Trouble the Water Vicky Cristina Barcelona The Visitor WALL-E Waltz with Bashir Wanted The Wrestler
Mine:
1. Rachel Getting Married (***1/2) 2. WALL-E (***1/2) 3. Encounters at the End of the World (***1/2) 4. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (***1/2) 5. Hellboy II: The Golden Army (***) 6. Happy-Go-Lucky (***) 7. Milk (***) 8. The Dark Knight (***) 9. The Wrestler (***) 10. In Bruges (***) 11. Iron Man (***) 12. Slumdog Millionaire (***) 13. The Betrayal (***) 14. Man On Wire (***) 15. Kung Fu Panda (***) 16. Doubt (**1/2) 17. Changeling (**1/2) 18. The Visitor (**1/2) 19. Vicky Cristina Barcelona (**1/2) 20. Tropic Thunder (**1/2) 21. Frost/Nixon (**) 22. Defiance (**) 23. Wanted (*1/2) 24. Revolutionary Road (*1/2) 25. Frozen River (*1/2) 26. The Reader (*1/2)
|
| Fri Feb 20, 2009 2:34 am |
|
 |
|
Vic
|
 Re: Rank/rate the Oscar nominees (all categories)
-
Last edited by Vic on Sun Feb 22, 2009 8:57 am, edited 1 time in total.
|
| Fri Feb 20, 2009 2:44 am |
|
 |
|
Robert Holloway
|
 Re: Rank/rate the Oscar nominees (all categories)
All scores out of 10
Australia - not seen The Baader Meinhof Complex - not seen The Betrayal - not seen 1 Bolt 5/10 2 Changeling 8/10 3 The Curious Case of Benjamin Button 5/10 after two viewings 4 The Dark Knight 9/10 originally 10/10 after the first screening - now seen it 3 times 5 Defiance 5/10 6 Doubt 7/10 7 The Duchess 5/10 8 Encounters at the End of the World 8/10 Entre Les Murs - Not seen 9 Frost/Nixon 8/10 10 Frozen River 6/10 The Garden - Not seen 11 Happy-Go-Lucky - 7/10 12 Hellboy II: The Golden Army 8/10 13 In Bruges - 8/10 14 Iron Man - 8/10 15 Kung Fu Panda 7/10 16 Man On Wire 9/10 17 Milk 8/10 Okuribito - Not seen 19 The Reader 6/10 20 Rachel Getting Married 7/10 Revanche - Not seen 21 Revolutionary Road - 8/10 22 Slumdog Millionaire - 9/10 23 Tropic Thunder - 7/10 Trouble the Water - Not seen 24 Vicky Cristina Barcelona - 7/10 25 The Visitor 8/10 26 WALL-E - 10/10 Waltz with Bashir - Not seen grrr 27 Wanted - 6/10 28 The Wrestler 9/10
and what of...? The Band's Visit 9/10 Boy A 8/10 Chop Shop 8/10 Flow For The Love Of Water 8/10 Forgetting Sarah Marshall 8/10 Gonzo.... 8/10 Hunger 8/10 In Search of a Midnight Kiss 8/10 I've Loved You For So Long 8/10 Gran Torino 8/10 Miss Pettigrew Lives For Day 8/10 My Winnipeg 8/10 Paranoid Park 8/10 Roman Polanski Wanted and Desired 8/10 Son Of Rambow 8/10 Spiderwick Chronicles 8/10 Tell No One 8/10 Young @ Heart 8/10 Rob
|
| Fri Feb 20, 2009 3:14 am |
|
 |
|
Trevor
|
 Re: Rank/rate the Oscar nominees (all categories)
All ratings out of 4 stars.
Australia ***1/2 #9 The Baader Meinhof Complex unseen The Betrayal unseen Bolt **1/2 Changeling unseen The Curious Case of Benjamin Button *** #10 The Dark Knight ***1/2 #5 Defiance unseen Doubt ***1/2 #8 The Duchess unseen Encounters at the End of the World unseen Entre Les Murs unseen Frost/Nixon *** Frozen River unseen The Garden unseen Happy-Go-Lucky unseen Hellboy II: The Golden Army *** In Bruges unseen Iron Man *** Kung Fu Panda *** Man On Wire unseen Milk unseen Okuribito unseen The Reader unseen Rachel Getting Married unseen Revanche unseen Revolutionary Road ***1/2 #7 Slumdog Millionaire **** #1 Tropic Thunder ***1/2 #6 Trouble the Water unseen Vicky Cristina Barcelona *** The Visitor unseen WALL-E *** Waltz with Bashir **** #2 Wanted *** The Wrestler **** #3
Thought I'd seen more of the nominees, guess I have some work to do yet.
|
| Fri Feb 20, 2009 5:38 am |
|
 |
|
gkanchan
|
 Re: Rank/rate the Oscar nominees (all categories)
Australia - ** The Baader Meinhof Complex - didnt see The Betrayal - didnt see Bolt - *** Changeling - *** 1/2 The Curious Case of Benjamin Button - *** 1/2 (#8) The Dark Knight - **** (#1) Defiance - *** 1/2 Doubt - *** 1/2 (#4) The Duchess - *** Encounters at the End of the World - didnt see Entre Les Murs - didnt see Frost/Nixon - *** Frozen River - ** 1/2 The Garden - *** Happy-Go-Lucky - *** Hellboy II: The Golden Army - *** In Bruges - *** Iron Man - *** 1/2 Kung Fu Panda - ** 1/2 Man On Wire - *** 1/2 Milk - *** 1/2 (#7) Okuribito - didnt see The Reader - *** Rachel Getting Married - **** (#3) Revanche - didnt see Revolutionary Road - *** 1/2 (#10) Slumdog Millionaire - *** 1/2 (#9) Tropic Thunder - *** 1/2 (#5) Trouble the Water - didnt see Vicky Cristina Barcelona - *** The Visitor - *** WALL-E - **** (#2) Waltz with Bashir - *** Wanted - *** The Wrestler - ***
Number in brackets would represent the positions of those movies in my top 10 of 08.
|
| Fri Feb 20, 2009 7:36 am |
|
 |
|
ed_metal_head
|
 Re: Rank/rate the Oscar nominees (all categories)
Changeling 6/10 The Dark Knight 9/10 Doubt 8/10 The Duchess 6/10 Frost/Nixon 7/10 Frozen River 8/10 Hellboy II: The Golden Army 7/10 In Bruges 7/10 Iron Man 7/10 Milk 8/10 The Reader 6/10 Revolutionary Road 8/10 Slumdog Millionaire 8/10 Tropic Thunder 7/10 Vicky Cristina Barcelona 8/10 The Visitor 7/10 WALL-E 8/10 Wanted 5/10 The Wrestler 8/10
2008 seemed a whole lot weaker than 2007 to me.
|
| Fri Feb 20, 2009 11:30 am |
|
 |
|
Pedro
|
 Re: Rank/rate the Oscar nominees (all categories)
Australia (B-) The Baader Meinhof Complex (N/A) The Betrayal (B+) Bolt (B) Changeling (B) The Curious Case of Benjamin Button (B+) The Dark Knight (A) Defiance (its soundtrack didn't impress me) Doubt (B) The Duchess (B-) Encounters at the End of the World (B+) Entre Les Murs (A-) Frost/Nixon (B+) Frozen River (A-) The Garden (B) Happy-Go-Lucky (B+) Hellboy II: The Golden Army (B) In Bruges (B) Iron Man (A-) Kung Fu Panda (B+) Man On Wire (A-) Milk (B+) Okuribito (N/A) The Reader (B) Rachel Getting Married (A-) Revanche (N/A) Revolutionary Road (B+) Slumdog Millionaire (A) Tropic Thunder (B) Trouble the Water (C) Vicky Cristina Barcelona (B-) The Visitor (B+) WALL-E (A-) Waltz with Bashir (A-) Wanted (B-) The Wrestler (A-)
By an large, a good collection of films.
|
| Tue Feb 24, 2009 3:18 am |
|
 |
|
ilovemovies
Director
Joined: Tue Apr 14, 2009 11:04 am Posts: 1379
|
 Re: Rank/rate the Oscar nominees (all categories)
Haven't seen: Waltz with Bashir, The Visitor, Trouble the Water, Slumdog Millionaire, Revolutionary Road, Revanche, Okuribito, Man On Wire, Happy-Go-Lucky, The Garden, Frozen River, Entre Les Murs, Encounters at the End of the World, The Baader Meinhof Complex, The Betrayal, Bolt, Milk .
On a **** scale:
19. Tropic Thunder - * 1/2 18. Vicky Cristina Barcelona - ** 17. The Duchess - ** 16. Wall-E - ** 1/2 15. In Bruges - ** 1/2 14. Kung Fu Panda - *** 13. The Reader - *** 12. Hellboy II: The Golden Army - *** 11. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button - ***
10. Iron Man - *** 09. Changeling - *** 08. Frost/Nixon - *** 07. Wanted - *** 06. Doubt - *** 05. The Wrestler - *** 04. Australia - *** 1/2 03. Defiance - *** 1/2 02. The Dark Knight - *** 1/2 01. Rachel Getting Married - *** 1/2
|
| Tue Apr 14, 2009 1:38 pm |
|
|
|
Page 1 of 1
|
[ 8 posts ] |
|
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot post attachments in this forum
|
|